Chapter 9: Fact and Opinion
Lab Activity 43: Reading Critically in Context
 
Objective:
To identify an author's use of facts and opinions in reading passages.

arrow.gifStep 2: Read the following paragraphs, and answer the questions that follow.


     

Modern operas are performed far less frequently than favorites such as La Traviata. Theaters are afraid to take chances. The cost of producing any opera is so high that even with the support of generous patrons, companies can barely break even. None can depend on ticket sales alone. Frequently, patrons demand time-honored classics. Now and then, however, a company dares to break with tradition and will commission a work by a composer whose credentials are above question.

—Janaro & Altshuler, The Art of Being Human 7th ed., p. 301.


6. The sentence, "Theaters are afraid to take chances" is an example of  

 
 
 


      7. "The cost of producing any opera is so high that even with the support of generous patrons, companies can barely break even."

A biased word in this sentence is  

 
 
 
 


      8. "The cost of producing any opera is so high that even with the support of generous patrons, companies can barely break even."

This sentence is an example of  

 
 
 


      9. "Frequently, patrons demand time-honored classics."

The biased word in this sentence is  

 
 
 
 


     

A pioneer work in American opera was composed in 1911 by Scott Joplin (1868–1917), famous for his innovations in ragtime. Titled Tremonisha, it was the first major opera by an African American, and in 1911 it was snubbed by the opera establishment. Joplin, already a success because of his ragtime achievements, had to publish the work himself. In 1915 it was finally produced and received generally unfavorable notices.

—Janaro & Altshuler, The Art of Being Human, 7th ed., p. 301.


10. The sentence "A pioneer work in American opera was composed in 1911 by Scott Joplin (1868–1917), famous for his innovations in ragtime" is an example of  

 
 
 


      11. "Titled Tremonisha, it was the first major opera by an African American, and in 1911 it was snubbed by the opera establishment."

This statement expresses  

 
 
 


      12. "Joplin, already a success because of his ragtime achievements, had to publish the work himself."

This statement expresses  

 
 
 


      13. "In 1915 it was finally produced and received generally unfavorable notices."

This is an example of  

 
 
 


     

Two possible reasons come to mind to explain the opera's failure. One may be that the opera world, almost exclusively a white institution, resented Joplin's effort to create grand opera rather than continue producing music "appropriate" for his cultural heritage. Another may be that audiences who knew and loved Joplin's music were expecting a ragtime opera, but Joplin wanted to go lightly in his use of the tempo that had served him so well. Although there is some ragtime, he may have wanted to show that music transcended narrow racial ties.

—Janaro & Altshuler, The Art of Being Human, 7th ed., pp. 301–302.


14. The sentence "One may be that the opera world, almost exclusively a white institution, resented Joplin's effort to create grand opera rather than continue producing music 'appropriate' for his cultural heritage" states 

 
 
 


      15. "Another may be that audiences who knew and loved Joplin's music were expecting a ragtime opera, but Joplin wanted to go lightly in his use of the tempo that had served him so well."

This sentence is an example of  

 
 
 


      16. "Although there is some ragtime, he may have wanted to show that music transcended narrow racial ties."

This sentence is an example of 

 
 
 


     

As happens over and over in the history of humanities, time has reversed the original criticism. Tremonisha is now widely accepted as the first truly American opera, using American subject matter and American folk themes along with a symphonic score inspired by Wagner's music. Although Joplin did in fact admire Wagner above all composers and even followed in the German composer's footsteps by writing both libretto and music, the result has been a recognized masterpiece in the romantic tradition that combine traditional forms with American motifs.

17. In this passage, the first sentence states  

 
 
 


      18. "Tremonisha is now widely accepted as the first truly American opera, using American subject matter and American folk themes along with a symphonic score inspired by Wagner's music."

A biased word in this sentence is  

 
 
 
 


      19. "Tremonisha is now widely accepted as the first truly American opera, using American subject matter and American folk themes along with a symphonic score inspired by Wagner's music."

This sentence expresses  

 
 
 


      20. "Although Joplin did in fact admire Wagner above all composers and even followed in the German composer's footsteps by writing both libretto and music, the result has been a recognized masterpiece in the romantic tradition that combine traditional forms with American motifs."

This sentence states 

 
 
 







Copyright © 1995-2010 by Pearson Education, Inc., publishing as Pearson Longman. Legal Disclaimer