![]() |
|
|
Chapter 1: A Reading System for Effective Readers Lab Activity 1: Prior Knowledge |
|
|
Objective To determine the prior knowledge a reader needs to achieve comprehension.
1 Leonardo goes far beyond realism in another masterpiece, the Mona Lisa of 1503–1505. The work is so famous that it still attracts huge numbers of visitors to the Louvre Museum in Paris, even though it is encased in bullet-proof glass behind a railing. 2 What is all the fuss about? How do we account for the incredible stature of this relatively small canvas in the world of humanities? One reason, of course, may be that widely discussed mysterious smile. One does not find many smiles in portrait paintings, because the artist has customarily been hired to render both a realistic likeness and an idealization in the classic mode. The David of Michelangelo is a good example of a Renaissance work that is both an imitation of a real human being and a perfected version of what a human being should look like. The famous smile particularizes Mona Lisa Giaconda, whom Leonardo was commissioned to paint. She is not only idealized in the traditional manner of portraiture, but she is also an individual woman captured in a particular inner action at a particular time. 3 A closer look at the painting, however, reveals that the mouth is shown with only the faintest trace of smile. Just as interesting is that Signora Giaconda is looking at something not shown in the painting-just what we can never know-which adds to the mystery. (Hint: If you'd like to leave behind a painting or a poem that people will still be talking about centuries from now, be sure there is an unsolvable mystery about it.) 4 The following experiment, suggested by one art critic, can be performed right this moment. Cover the left side of the face, using your hand or an index card. Presumably, you will see a warm, sensuous woman, gazing provocatively, at you! Now cover the right side, and presumably you will see an aristocrat who finds something (not you, of course) mildly amusing. Many have said that Leonardo in this work has revealed the essential ambiguity of all human faces and personalities. If we agree, we could say that the Mona Lisa accomplishes a goal many artists seek but rarely achieve: its creator has both particularized and generalized. What should, however, stand out in our mind is that the portrait is a supreme example of the Renaissance movement toward individualism or, rather, the support given by all the arts to a rebellion against the medieval emphasis on an afterlife rather than in the rich diversity found in this life. 5 Later in the same century Shakespeare would create monumental and decidedly individual characters like Hamlet, Othello, Lear, Macbeth, Lady Macbeth, and Cleopatra. Yes, they offer insights into many universal human traits and weaknesses, but they are also three-dimensional beings firmly rooted in their unique situations and speaking in a language so specific to each that lovers of Shakespeare can usually identify major characters even when all names are omitted from the text. Adapted from Janaro and Altshuler, The Art of Being Human, 7th ed., pp. 159–60 Copyright © 1995-2008 by Pearson Education, Inc., publishing as Pearson Longman. Legal Disclaimer |